Overview

In recent years, the difference between initial Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) awards and those granted at appeal has widened significantly. In 2024/25, the average initial offer of £7,710 increased by more than £48,000 at appeal - to £55,800 - representing a 624% increase. This growing disparity highlights serious concerns about how initial offers are assessed and the importance of robust, well-prepared appeals on behalf of victims and survivors.

This masterclass, presented by Neil Sugarman, provides a detailed and practical exploration of the CICA appeals process. Delegates will examine the legislative framework, procedural rules, and practical considerations for maximising outcomes in appeal cases. From time limits and evidence gathering to drafting appeals and navigating post-hearing steps, this session will equip practitioners with the tools and confidence to advocate effectively for clients.

Learning outcomes

By the end of this session, delegates will be able to:

• Understand the statutory framework governing CICA appeals.
• Identify the key legislation and relevant bodies involved in CICA claims and appeals.
• Recognise common circumstances leading to appeal and how to approach them strategically.
• Apply time limits and procedural requirements effectively.
• Draft persuasive and well-structured appeals.
• Manage interim and pre-hearing procedures with efficiency.
• Prepare and present robust evidence in support of appeals.
• Anticipate and address issues arising at the hearing.
• Understand the post-hearing process and potential for further challenge.
• Appreciate how judicial review fits into the wider CICA appeals framework.
• Analyse recent appeal trends and outcomes to inform practice.
• Advocate effectively for clients to secure fair and proportionate compensation.