Loading...
A not-for-profit organisation
committed to injured people
A not-for-profit organisation
committed to injured people

Will an insurer pay for this - Insurers, insolvent defendants, the MIB and finding someone who can actually pay the claim

CPD
1 hour
Target audience
Any level

Important Court of Appeal decision on the Third Party (Rights against Insurers) Act 1990

The Court of Appeal’s decision yesterday in Makin v The Restaurant Muse Limited & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 1367 illustrates the potentially devastating consequences of an insured defendant’s failure to comply with its policy. Despite obtaining judgment against the insolvent defendant, the injured claimant could not recover from its insurer because of failures to notify the incident and forward correspondence.

The Court held that the relevant policy requirements were conditions precedent to the insurer’s liability, even though they were not expressly labelled as such. The insurer did not have to demonstrate that the breaches had caused it any prejudice. The claimant’s rights under the Third Parties (Rights against Insurers) Act 2010 did not overcome those policy defences.

These practical problems will be explored in “Will an insurer pay for this? Insurers, insolvent defendants, the MIB and finding someone who can actually pay the claim”, on 30 October 2026. 

The webinar will consider the obstacles to recovering  damages and the importance of identifying insurance issues and potential sources of payment at an early stage.

Who is going to pay the damages?

This is one of the most important questions a claimant lawyer should ask at the outset of every case – but it is surprisingly easy to overlook. A defendant may be insolvent. A company may have ceased trading. An employer may have disappeared. An insurer may deny that the policy responds. There may be a substantial policy excess or deductible. A business may have transferred to another company. The identity of the relevant insurer may not even be known.
A claimant can have an excellent case on liability and quantum and still face a fundamental problem:

Is there anyone worth suing?

This webinar looks at the routes available to practitioners when the person or company primarily liable cannot – or will not – meet the claim. It is an updated version of the webinar last presented in September 2025 and includes important developments during 2026.

The webinar will consider the recent Court of Appeal decision in ABC v Huntercombe (No.12) Ltd & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 1161.

Content

The webinar takes a practical approach to identifying who will ultimately meet a judgment

Topics include:

  • The starting point – investigate recoverability before spending years litigating the claim.
  • Identifying the insurer – what information can be obtained and from whom?
  • The Third Parties (Rights Against Insurers) Act 2010 – when can the claimant proceed directly against an insurer?
  • What happens when the defendant is insolvent?
  • Obtaining information about insurance cover before proceedings are issued.
  • Policy coverage disputes – what happens when the insurer says the policy does not respond?
  • Policy limits, excesses and deductibles – the crucial distinction between the existence of insurance and the availability of insurance money to meet the claim.
  • Employers' liability insurance – tracing historic cover.
  • Public liability insurance – what practitioners need to establish.
  • Companies which have been dissolved or entered liquidation – identifying the correct procedural route.
  • TUPE and vicarious liability – the implications of the Court of Appeal's decision in ABC v Huntercombe.
  • Road traffic claims – the insurer's statutory liability under the Road Traffic Act.
  • Uninsured and untraced drivers – when the MIB becomes relevant.
  • Article 75 and insurer status issues.
  • Claims involving insolvent insurers – what alternative sources of compensation may exist?


Presented by Gordon Exall

Barrister
Kings Chambers, Leeds, Manchester and Birmingham and 4-5 Gray's Inn Square, London

Gordon was called to the Bar in 1991 having originally qualified and practised as a solicitor. He practices from Kings Chambers, Leeds, Manchester and Birmingham and 4-5 Gray's Inn Square, London. He works in the area of personal injury litigation and in the law relating to civil procedure, limitation and costs. He has a particular interest in issues relating to damages, evidence, costs and procedure.  

Gordon is a former executive committee member of APIL and has lectured widely for APIL and CPIL on personal injury and procedure topics. Gordon is the author of  Personal Injury Practice Notes (Cavendish); The APIL Guide to Fatal Accidents (now in its 4th edition); the 14th edition of Munkman and Exall on Damages for Personal Injury Death and Periodical Payments the New Law. He also wrote the section on limitation for the APIL loose-leaf and contributes two chapters to Munkman on Employer’s Liability... view full biography

Personal injury legal training header
Published
30 October 2026
On-demand recording
Available from 30 October 2026
On-demand recording
Recording access for 6 months post-event
Delegate rate
From £90 + VAT
Personal injury legal training header
Live or on-demand

Join live to take part in polls, ask questions, and get the full interactive experience.

Unable to attend live? No problem - everyone who registers will receive access to the on-demand recording, available to watch anytime for up to six months.