This session provides a practical update on alternative dispute resolution (ADR) in civil litigation, focusing on the increasing importance of ADR within the Civil Procedure Rules and the potential consequences of failing to engage appropriately.
It will begin with an update on CPR requirements, court directions and costs consequences, including the courts' powers to order parties to engage in ADR and the implications of unreasonable refusal or failure to participate. The session will consider the significance of Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council and how the courts' approach to ADR has developed.
The session will then explore and contrast three important ADR processes:
- Facilitative mediation – where the mediator helps the parties communicate, identify interests and negotiate their own settlement.
- Evaluative mediation – where the mediator takes a more interventionist approach, testing the parties' positions and providing views on the strengths and weaknesses of the case.
- Neutral Evaluation / Early Neutral Evaluation (ENE) – where an independent neutral evaluates the dispute and provides an informed assessment, potentially helping the parties to reassess their positions.
Finally, the session will focus on how to succeed at ADR in practice, with particular emphasis on preparing both yourself and your client. This will cover strategic preparation, understanding the client's real objectives, assessing risk, developing settlement authority and ensuring that the right people and information are available to make meaningful decisions on the day.
Frances McCarthy is managing partner of Pattinson & Brewer where she heads up the personal injury department. She is the past president of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers and is a former member of the Civil Justice Council.
She is qualified CEDR mediator and jointly with Tim Wallis mediated various costs issues at the request of the Civil Justice Council, including the levels of success fees to be claimed in personal injury cases. She helped to set up Trust Mediation with Tim Wallis, Sir Henry Brook and others.
She is a senior fellow of APIL and was a member of Lord Woolf’s working party which developed the personal injury pre-action protocols... view full biography
Tim Wallis is a solicitor (1978), a mediator (2004) and Chair of Trust Mediation (TM) (2013) a provider of specialist mediators for personal injury and clinical negligence claims. Tim led TM’s tender bid to conduct pi and clin neg mediations under the NHS Resolution mediation scheme. He contributes the ADR sections for “The White Book” and “APIL Personal Injury Law, Practice and Precedents” and he commissioned the publication of “The Jackson ADR Handbook” on behalf of the Civil Justice Council. Special interests: un-settleable claims, multi-party claims and online dispute resolution. TM settlement rates: approx. 85%+ pi and 75%+ clin neg. ... view full biography