Association of Personal Injury Lawyers logo
Association of Personal Injury Lawyers

Enterprise Bill ‘grossly unfair’ to injured workers

15 Apr 2013
APIL news

A Government proposal which would undermine the rights of injured workers returns to the House of Commons tomorrow (Tuesday 16 April) after being thrown out by the House of Lords.

The Government plan will put the burden of proving an employer has caused needless injury or death back onto the victim. This tilts the playing field in favour of negligent bosses, who hold all the cards, and against vulnerable workers, who hold none. The employer always has the upper hand - he controls the workplace, he controls the work equipment used, and knows all the systems of the business inside out.

“This proposal is grossly unfair,” said Karl Tonks, president of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL). “It will make bringing some valid claims for compensation extremely difficult, and many people are likely to shy away from bringing a claim altogether.

“It is the duty of employers to provide safe workplaces, not the duty of employees to keep negligent bosses in check,” he went on. “Peers recognised the problems the Government’s proposal would cause during detailed debate in the House of Lords and MPs must understand that if the House of Lords amendment isn’t accepted tomorrow, many injured workers could be deterred from claiming the damages they need to put their lives back on track, leaving the state to pick up the tab.

“It will not cut ‘red-tape’ for business: cases which do go ahead will take longer, they will be more complicated, and inevitably costs will be higher. Prosecutions for workplace accidents are already few and far between, and if it becomes harder to claim compensation as well, negligent employers will be even less accountable for their actions. Rogue bosses are likely to take advantage by cutting corners with health and safety requirements.” The proposal was defeated in the House of Lords, where Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Haywood, a former Supreme Court Justice, highlighted the difficulties experienced by workers in proving the negligence of their employers. He said that, when he worked as a barrister, a number claims were lost “because the claimants were not able to assemble all the evidence necessary to prove actual negligence.”

Tonks went on, “Lord Brown’s comments go to the heart of the matter. People injured through no fault of their own will find it extremely challenging to secure justice. If MPs don’t support the lords’ conclusions tomorrow, the effects are likely to be profound, with unintended consequences which will not just affect the workers involved, but society as a whole.”


Notes to editors:

  • APIL (Association of Personal Injury Lawyers) is a not-for-profit organisation whose members are dedicated to campaigning for improvements in the law to help people who are injured or become ill through no fault of their own.
  • For more information contact APIL's press and communications officers Jane Hartwell on t: 0115 943 5416, m: 07808 768623, e:, or Tim Carter t: 0115 943 5409, e:
  • Visit the association's website at
  • •Follow @APIL on Twitter:

Past press releases

Government abandons full compensation for injured people, 23 Oct 2018
Extra pressure on NHS if Civil Liability Bill goes ahead, 03 Sep 2018
Bereaved relatives deserve fairness, 31 Aug 2018
Cut whiplash injuries with the headrest test, 15 Aug 2018
Grieving parents of stillborn babies fight for answers, 22 Jun 2018
Lawyers call for outright ban on cold calling for personal injury in Scotland, 01 Jun 2018
APIL, FOIL and MASS join forces for mediation project, 29 May 2018
Grieving relatives cruelly ignored by justice system, 27 Apr 2018

More past press releases

Head of Public Affairs
Lorraine Gwinnutt
0115 943 5400

Communications Manager
Jane Hartwell
0115 943 5416

Press & Communications Officer
Lizzy Freeman
0115 943 5431