Association of Personal Injury Lawyers logo
Association of Personal Injury Lawyers

Pressure on the pricing of car insurance premiums and the imminent review of the discount rate

03 Feb 2017
APIL news

Lawyers accuse insurers of “sickening” blame game tactics

Statement from Neil Sugarman, president of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) in response to latest news from the Association of British Insurers (ABI) about the pressure on the pricing of car insurance premiums, and the Lord Chancellor’s imminent review of the discount rate* for personal injury claims:
“People with life-changing, debilitating injuries face a shortfall in their compensation which in some cases could mean decades of their care needs are not accounted for, because the discount rate for personal injury is too high. The pressure and stress of this uncertainty for families is immeasurable. For insurers to try to deny these people of their very real need for compensation with the threat of higher car insurance premiums is a sickening tactic to shift the blame for the industry’s failure to control premiums.
Nothing about the long-overdue review of the discount rate is ‘sudden’. Insurers have got away with undercompensating people with catastrophic injuries for years and they know it. There are some public and private sector compensators, including the NHS Litigation Authority and Direct Line, who have managed to account for the likelihood of a change to the discount rate when determining their reserves for futures liabilities. Excuses from the Association of British Insurers (ABI) that the insurance industry has not had chance to prepare for a new rate do not wash.
For insurers to treat injured people as a mere nuisance is nothing new. Latest data from the ABI is a shameless ‘pick n’ mix’ of figures which obscure the long-established fact that personal injury claims are not the reason for rising premiums. The ABI’s own data shows that the cost of motor-related injury claims have been falling since 2013. But the ABI cannot sink much lower than it has right now. It has turned its guns on people with disabilities and life-long care needs, the result of needless injuries inflicted by their members’ policyholders. Clearly the ABI would rather insurers did not honour their responsibilities to pay full and fair compensation.”
* A discount is applied to compensation payments to offset the accumulation of interest (net of income tax and inflation) from the investment of the compensation, such as in a bank or building society. The rate has not been reviewed or altered since 2001 when interest rates were much higher than in recent years.

Past statements and comments

Fixed costs for personal injury claims against the NHS: APIL response, 15 Feb 2018
MoJ decides on April 2019 to implement whiplash reforms, 12 Feb 2018
APIL's response to the Justice Select Committee report , 30 Nov 2017
APIL's reaction to a court of appeal ruling in relation to eligibility for bereavement damages, 28 Nov 2017
Rapid resolution and redress scheme , 28 Nov 2017
Reaction to Government's response to consultation on setting the discount rate, 07 Sep 2017
Response to National Audit Office report and recommendations for managing the costs of clinical negligence in trusts, 06 Sep 2017
Discount rate reduction from 2.5% to -0.75% for personal injury claims: Statement from the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL), 27 Feb 2017

More past statements

Head of Public Affairs
Lorraine Gwinnutt
0115 943 5400

Communications Manager
Jane Hartwell
0115 943 5416

Press & Communications Officer
Lizzy Freeman
0115 943 5431