Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
A not-for-profit organisation representing injured people

Response to ministerial statement on tackling unjustified personal injury claims

15 Jun 2014
APIL news

Ministerial statement – tackling unjustified personal injury claims

Response from the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL)

There is much in the Government’s proposals which we welcome – we have, for example, been involved for some time in meetings with the Ministry of Justice and other stakeholders to improve standards of medical reporting in whiplash claims.

APIL has also been calling for years for a universal ban on cash and other inducements, so we welcome this approach. It’s important, though, that the same standards are applied to insurers, so that vulnerable people are protected.

We absolutely do not condone fraud or exaggeration, but it’s important to be clear about what is meant by these terms. At the moment, the situation is anything but clear.

If it can be proved to a criminal standard that an entire claim is fraudulent, there is no doubt that it should be thrown out. But what is considered exaggeration by an insurer can, to a claimant, be a very valid argument which the claimant has simply been unable to prove at a particular stage of the case. The law is rarely black and white, which is why the courts already have the power to use discretion to deal with alleged exaggeration. To introduce the power for blanket dismissal in this way will lead to three things: an increase in spurious allegations of fraud and exaggeration by insurers; an increase in satellite litigation, and an increase in the number of genuine claimants who either underplay their symptoms or who fail to bring valid cases at all, for fear of being falsely accused.

And the Government does not go far enough in its proposal to restrict the practice of settling whiplash claims without confirmation of injury. This practice plays a significant part in encouraging fraud, which is why APIL has called for an outright ban on pre-medical offers.

Past statements and comments

Lord Chancellor announces start of discount rate review – APIL response, 19 Mar 2019
NHS Resolution annual report 2017/18: Reaction from the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL), 13 Jul 2018
Civil Liability Bill debate on whiplash reform in the House of Lords - reaction from the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL), 13 Jun 2018
Reaction from the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) to the Justice Select Committee report on increasing the small claims limit for personal injury (17 May 2018), 17 May 2018
Fixed costs for personal injury claims against the NHS: APIL response, 15 Feb 2018
MoJ decides on April 2019 to implement whiplash reforms, 12 Feb 2018
APIL's response to the Justice Select Committee report , 30 Nov 2017
APIL's reaction to a court of appeal ruling in relation to eligibility for bereavement damages, 28 Nov 2017

More past statements

Head of Public Affairs
Lorraine Gwinnutt
0115 943 5400

Communications Manager
Jane Hartwell
0115 943 5416

Press & Communications Officer
Lizzy Freeman
0115 943 5431