Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
A not-for-profit organisation representing injured people

Medical Innovation Bill threatens to ‘erode patient safety’

25 Apr 2014
APIL news

A draft Bill designed to give doctors the freedom to practise innovative medicine on patients is both dangerous and unnecessary, said lawyers in response to a Government consultation which closes today.

The Medical Innovation Bill, devised by Lord Saatchi, aims to save lives by removing a perceived fear of litigation from doctors who wish to use innovative techniques. But the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) says the unintended consequence of the Bill would be the erosion of patient safety.

“While this Bill is clearly well-intended, it is actually based on myth and misconception,” said APIL president Matthew Stockwell. “Doctors already have the freedom to use innovative techniques – only last month, it was reported that a survivor of a motorbike accident had received pioneering surgery to reconstruct his face.

“The fact is that the current system allows such innovation to take place while providing safeguards for patients, something which this Bill fails to do.

“Current law expects a doctor to act in a way which would be supported by a responsible body of medical opinion,” Mr Stockwell explained. “This is critical because seriously ill and dying patients are particularly vulnerable.

“It is extremely important that patients are able to discuss treatment with their doctors while being protected by the robust but flexible checks and balances which are currently in place.”

In its response to the Department of Health consultation,the association argues there is no evidence to support the idea that litigation has increased as a result of innovative medicine.

“The individual needs of patients must come first,” said Mr Stockwell. “If there is a culture of fear among doctors that innovation could lead to litigation, it should be dealt with through education, not legislation.” 

“And a change of culture should also include addressing other genuine problems which are preventing innovation, such as a lack of funding and resources for medical research.”


Notes to editors:

  • APIL (Association of Personal Injury Lawyers) is a not-for-profit organisation whose members are dedicated to campaigning for improvements in the law to help people who are injured or become ill through no fault of their own.
  • For more information contact APIL's press and communications officers Jane Hartwell on t: 0115 943 5416, m: 07808 768623, e:, or Tim Carter t: 0115 943 5409, e:
  • Visit the association's website at
  • •Follow @APIL on Twitter:

Past press releases

‘Milestone’ appointment to the APIL board, 24 Jan 2022
Bereaved families must not be sidelined in coroner plans, 13 Jan 2022
New report gives voice to “devastated” NHS patients, 12 Jan 2022
Commissioner needed to solve patient safety crisis, 02 Nov 2021
Public wants ban on injury compensation calls and texts , 08 Sep 2021
Action needed now to stop the misery of needless injuries, 04 Aug 2021
Injury Prevention Week: it’s common sense!, 02 Aug 2021
Principle of openness 'undermined' by plans for patient safety probes, 14 Jul 2021

More past press releases

Head of Public Affairs
Lorraine Gwinnutt
0115 943 5400

Communications Manager
Jane Hartwell
0115 943 5416

Press & Communications Officer
Iman Anthony
0115 943 5431